The 3 Best Sleep Masks of 2024 | Reviews by Wirecutter

Nov 02, 2024

By Caira Blackwell

Caira Blackwell is a senior staff writer covering Sleep. She's tested a dozen mattresses at home—and yes, she tells people she sleeps for a living.

After a new round of testing, we’ve added the soft, contoured Mzoo Sleep Mask as a pick in the guide. The Alaska Bear Natural Silk Sleep Mask and the lightweight, convex Nidra Deep Rest Eye Mask remain picks.

24-hour light exposure is a fairly new concept in human evolution. Television screens, phones, laptops, street lamps, and blaring overhead lights around the clock can disrupt your circadian rhythm—the 24-hour cycle that’s governed by your body’s internal clock—and make it harder to fall and stay asleep. If your bedroom isn’t as dark as it should be, or you need to sleep during the day, a sleep mask can help.

We tested 14 masks by assessing their materials, sleeping with them for at least two nights each, and evaluating their fit on a variety of face shapes and head sizes. We found three options—a silky-smooth crowd-pleaser, a padded memory-foam mask, and a lightweight contoured mask—that are well made, comfortable all night, and excellent at blocking out light.

First and foremost, we focused on sleep masks that were adept at creating total darkness.

We asked several people with a variety of face and nose shapes to wear the masks we chose.

The mask lies directly on your face, so the softer it is, the better. We preferred masks made of soft, breathable material.

A good sleep mask blocks out most light, but a great sleep mask feels so good you forget you’re wearing it.

Advertisement

Wirecutter has been researching and testing sleep masks since 2017. For this guide, we did the following:

If you need to block out light from your sleep environment, a sleep mask can help. If you already use one (whether a freebie from a long-haul flight or an old bandana), it might be time to upgrade to one of our picks. Airline masks or bedazzled models—think Audrey Hepburn in Breakfast at Tiffany’s (video)—are typically not well designed (allowing light to creep in at the edges), or they’re so uncomfortable you may toss it off in the middle of the night.

The overhead lights in our homes, the street lights, and the glow from laptops, phones, and televisions have skyrocketed our average daily exposure to light, said Dr. Fariha Abbasi-Feinberg, a sleep doctor and spokesperson for the American Academy of Sleep Medicine. Over a third of Americans (PDF) report that outdoor or indoor light disrupts their sleep. Light exposure at night can make it harder to initially fall asleep and can cause you to wake up during the night, disrupting your transitions between your sleep cycles and degrading your overall quality of sleep. Creating a pitch-dark sleep environment can be hard to do, especially if you’re a frequent traveler or night-shift worker. Sleep masks are an affordable way to tackle that problem, and new research has even shown that wearing one at night helps with memory consolidation, the ability to learn, and alertness the next day. Sleep masks don’t cure insomnia (for that, we recommend speaking with your physician), but they should help you get better sleep.

We researched and tested dozens of blackout and room-darkening curtains and found the best ones for blocking out light, so you can sleep.

Advertisement

A silken exterior material, a flat design, and an adjustable strap make this mask a fit for almost any face, but it puts pressure on the eyes.

Best for: This mask is suitable for side-, back-, and stomach-sleepers who want a mask that sits flush against their face.

How it feels: This mask is silky smooth and breathable, so it doesn’t get hot when pressed against your skin all night.

It was popular among all testers, regardless of sleep style. The Alaska Bear Natural Silk Sleep Mask is comfortable, soft, and lightweight. All of our testers (whether back-, side-, or stomach-sleepers) had something that they liked about this mask, and it performed better than average in every testing consideration, including fit, adjustability, and comfort. If you’ve worn a traditional sleep mask before, this silk-lined style will feel familiar but remarkably more comfortable and softer on your skin.

It’s especially great for stomach-sleepers. Our testers who sleep on their stomach found that the convex sleep masks crumpled when their face made contact with their pillow, impeding their sleep. The Alaska Bear sleep mask, on the other hand, stays flush, even when sandwiched between a pillow and your face. Both sides of the mask design are lined with mulberry silk, which remains breathable even when pressed against the skin.

It fits a range of faces and blocks light well. This silk mask is a good choice if convex sleep masks don’t suit your face or sleep style. The Alaska Bear sleep mask’s flat design fits nearly all face shapes and nose types. Even though this mask doesn’t seal around your face like our more structured picks, all of our testers reported that it did a decent job of blocking out light.

The adjustable strap is barely noticeable. Testers liked that you can adjust the strap with a small plastic buckle that didn’t bother back-sleepers and rarely got tangled in longer or curlier hair. One tester, who tried the Alaska Bear sleep mask in 2020 and again in 2024, said that “the mask stays on really well, as long as you tighten the strap every couple of nights.”

Soft, structured, and contoured, this mask stays on all night and prevents any light from seeping through.

Best for: This model suits side- and back-sleepers who need a little space between the mask and their eyes.

How it feels: This mask is soft against the skin and roomy around the eyes, and it drops the world into complete darkness the moment you put it on.

It stays in place all night. Even the side-sleepers on our testing panel, who noted that sleep masks don’t always work with their preferred sleep position, found that this mask stayed on throughout the night. One tester noted that the mask didn’t let light in around the nose bridge, even when they laid on their side.

It fully blocks light. One tester described this mask as “perfect for a nap in a sunny window.” It fully shuts out all light, whether you’re trying to sleep in broad sun or just need to stifle residual light at night.

Its padded, goggle-like design is especially comfortable. The Mzoo Sleep Mask’s eyecups have a convex gap so your eyes can open and close. That gap is surrounded by a memory foam padding that rests on the perimeter of your eye sockets. The effect is such that you don’t feel like your eyes are being forced closed, but there is a bit of compression near your temples, eyebrows, and cheekbones. Our testers found this sensation soothing. “They feel more like putting on goggles than a sleep mask, but they are sure to get the job done,” one tester said. Another liked how the contour of the eyecup kept the mask from brushing against their eyelashes, which makes it a good choice for people who wear eyelash extensions.

It’s adjustable. This mask is equipped with an adjustable plastic slider that ensures a snug fit for all head sizes and shapes. Only one tester thought that it was still slightly too big even after fastening it as tightly as the strap would allow.

Advertisement

Lightweight and contoured, this mask fits comfortably and blocks light well for a wide variety of face shapes. Its deep eyecups allow your eyes to flutter during sleep.

Best for: This mask will appeal to side- and back-sleepers who don’t want any added pressure to their eyes.

How it feels: This model is lightweight and roomy, and it rests gently on your face.

It has a lightweight, barely there feel. The polyester-covered, elastic-band Nidra Deep Rest Eye Mask has deep, wide cups that gently sit upon your eyes without applying any pressure (like our pick from Mzoo does). The Nidra sleep mask’s cavernous design leaves ample room for your eyes to move while you sleep, no matter how tightly you adjust its headband.

The design accommodates different face shapes. Spanning temple to temple on most faces, the Nidra mask covers more surface area than all the other sleep masks we tested, and it features a wider nose-bridge shape. This gap slopes gently without being too rigid, so it conforms to many more nose shapes, from narrow and arched noses with bridges to wider, flatter noses without bridges. The adjustable strap, which was redesigned in 2023 from a velcro closure to a plastic slider, secures a snug fit without snagging on hair.

It blocks light well. Because the mask is wide from temple to temple, testers reported that it did a great job keeping them in total darkness. One tester, who self-identified as having a small face and a big nose, found that all other masks let in a little light around the nose bridge, whereas the Nidra sleep mask did not.

In evaluating sleep masks, we looked for:

Light-blocking abilities: A good sleep mask blocks out most light, even if the sun is shining directly in your face.

A comfortable feel for all-night wear: Because the mask lies directly on your face, the softer and less noticeable it is, the better. We looked out for breathable materials like silk, which feels gentle against your eyelids yet keeps your face from getting too hot on swampy nights. Masks should also be lightweight (ideally no more than 1.5 ounces) but sturdy enough to hold their shape.

An adjustable strap: The strap should be able to fit heads of all sizes and shapes. Most mask straps rely on Velcro or a plastic fastener to create a snug fit. Our testers typically preferred buckled straps, which were less likely to get tangled in one’s hair.

Convex eyecups: Sleep masks that offer some space between your eyelids and the mask give your eyes room to move or flutter. Most testers found this type of design more comfortable than flat-style masks that felt heavy on their eyelids and lashes. If you don’t like that sensation or tend to fall asleep with your makeup still on, a convex, cup-style sleep mask is the way to go.

Versatile design: Sleep masks should suit a variety of face and nose shapes. We disqualified any options that bunched up on more-pronounced noses or let in too much light on flatter ones.

Durable and washable: Nightly wear causes unsavory levels of skin oils and eye gunk to build up on the underside of the mask. We considered masks that could stand up to frequent machine- or hand-washing.

In our most recent round of testing in 2024, we considered six masks and assessed their quality and versatility before sending them to a group of eight panelists to try at home. Each tester slept with each mask for at least one night and evaluated their performance based on comfort, ability to block out light, and whether or not they stayed on all night.

Advertisement

If you know you want a sleep mask for traveling or sitting upright: Consider the Manta Sleep Mask, which features two removable doughnut-shaped eyecups that you can Velcro onto the mask for a more precise fit. We found its eyecups, however, pressed uncomfortably against the face while our testers were sleeping on their side or stomach. The soft fabric of the mask felt less breathable than the foam or silk of our picks, and the material was uncomfortable in warm weather.

If you have a larger head: The Bucky 40 Blinks Sleep Mask is almost indistinguishable from the Nidra Deep Rest Eye Mask, save for a slightly stiffer foam build and a wider Velcro strap. Its accommodating strap offers a marginally better fit for larger heads than that of our pick from Nidra, though this also means the Bucky sleep mask’s strap forms a more noticeable bump behind your head. The mask’s V-shaped cutout, which is meant to go around the nose, is a little stiff and less malleable than that of the Nidra sleep mask. But if you have a larger head and prefer a mask with eyecups, the Bucky sleep mask may be a better choice.

We tested two other masks from Alaska Bear. The Alaska Bear 2-Strap Natural Silk Sleep Mask is a flat design like the one we recommend, but with the addition of a second strap and a flap of silk that can cover your nose. The double strap was hard to adjust, especially while half-asleep in the middle of the night. The nose baffle, meanwhile, barely prevented light from leaking in.

The Alaska Bear Memory Foam Sleep Mask is made of plush memory foam with indentations around the eyes, which initially seemed like a good compromise between flat and contoured masks. Our testers found that the mask blocked all visible light and was very comfortable to wear while they were sitting up—but when they slept on their stomach or side, the plush sides of the mask compressed uncomfortably.

The BeeVines Silk Sleep Mask (pack of two) is a flat, silk sleep mask. Although the material itself was soft against the skin, most testers didn’t like this mask—it’s small, doesn’t block light very well, and the adjustable plastic slider strap was too thin and pinched the skin behind their ears.

No one found the Bedtime Bliss Sleep Mask particularly comfortable during testing. Although it seems to be the spitting image of the Nidra Deep Rest Eye Mask, its smaller size and sharper nose contour make it less comfortable to wear.

The Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Eyemask was the softest mask we’ve tested, and it felt luxurious to the touch. But, many testers, even those with small faces, noted that it felt too tight, and it slipped off in the middle of the night.

The Freshme Cotton Sleep Mask wraps around your head and is made from 95% cotton and 5% spandex. Testers really liked the immersive experience of this mask, but the cotton can get hot. This mask would be a great option for sleeping on planes, trains, and buses, but wearing it all night might have you waking up in sweats.

Slip’s Sleep Mask is a fancy-looking mask that arrives in an even fancier case. The mask felt impressively smooth to the touch, but it has a scrunchie-like band instead of adjustable buckles or Velcro, and it felt much too small even for those with small heads.

The makers of the PrettyCare 3D Sleep Mask (pack of two) boast about the mask’s “large eye cavities” in its Amazon description, but we found that the mask had shallow cups. Our initial testers found the mask uncomfortable, and no one picked it as a favorite.

The Earth Therapeutics R.E.M Sleep Eye Mask is similar to the old, Velcro version of the Nidra sleep mask and has large convex eyecups and a gentle nose bridge. But the polyurethane foam and polyester material feels cheap and itchy against the skin.

Designed for travel, the Trtl Glimpse Sleep Mask has a fabric flap that you can pull up to “take a peek” without taking the mask off and letting in bright light. It’s a fun feature, but the entire mask was rather bulky, and it slipped easily.

Similar to the Trtl sleep mask, the Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Sleep Mask had heat and fit issues. A bouffant of velour-like memory foam, the mask felt heavy and needed to be tightened too much to prevent slipping. And the fabric made it too hot for comfort.

Sabrina Imbler wrote a previous version of this article, first published in 2017. This article was edited by Christina Colizza and Courtney Schley.

Advertisement

Caira Blackwell

Caira Blackwell is a senior staff writer covering sleep, and co-host of our podcast, The Wirecutter Show. She has spent countless hours testing more than 50 mattresses and has slept on nearly a dozen at home. Her work has been published in Nylon magazine, Okayplayer, and Narratively. When she isn’t busy sleeping (for work), she’s busy trying new recipes in the kitchen or reading in the sun.

by Christina Colizza

This bra-shaped sleep mask is great for back-sleepers and people who don’t like fabric touching their eyes.

by Lauren Dragan

After years of testing sleep headphones that proved to be a nightmare, we’ve found two pairs that help us sleep like a baby.

by Annemarie Conte

Even the quietest humidifier can keep some people up at night. Here’s how to get a good night’s rest if the whine causes you to lose sleep.

by Joanne Chen

Sound can be the most frustrating thing that keeps you from getting good sleep. Here’s how you can silence your sleep space.

Advertisement